Back To Your Regularly Scheduled War In 'Darkest Hour' | Episode 78.5

Posted December 15, 2017

-review by Chance Solem-Pfeifer

One of the simplest points that can be made about “Darkest Hour” is that it portrays the flip side of this summer’s “Dunkirk.” You could cut the two movies together — the horrifying beaches from one, the brooding before a war-room map from the other — into a piece of Oscar bait that would feel even more traditional than these 2017 WWII lionizations are on their own.

There’s a way of reading the Churchill-focused side of this duo as a worthy addendum to “Dunkirk.” The fact that they’ve come out in the same year isn’t the fault of “Darkest Hour.” But I’m not sure audiences are so spongy, so eager for historical detail that “Darkest Hour” gets a free pass on its closeness to Nolan’s summer blockbuster. The fact is we’ve already been to 1940 and Blitz-besieged Europe once this year (twice actually if you happened to see the BBC’s inoffensive and inessential “Their Finest”). Can a fairly standard biographical snapshot swell our emotions for the second time in six months about the same set of stakes?

While “Darkest Hour” imprisons its politicians in a series of oaken rooms, instead of the briggs and biplanes of “Dunkirk,” the feelings it attempts to elicit are the same ones — bravery, sacrifice, redemption, pure populism — connoted when Harry Styles hears Churchill’s famous May 1940 address aloud from the newspaper at the end of “Dunkirk.” That moment feels like a symphony for the common folk, and as innocent and apolitical a statement on WWII as one can muster while still making a movie about how the Allied troops were heroes. “Darkest Hour” crescendoing into Churchill delivering the same speech to Parliament feels more like a piece of chamber music for a brilliant, sometimes cloistered nationalist who was right for this particular moment.

Where this historical drama from Joe Wright (“Atonement,” “Pride and Prejudice”) really succeeds is more nebulous than the gravity of Gary Oldman’s Oscar-grasping performance lets on. Certainly, he’s transformed into a man 80 pounds heavier and whose famous witticisms are bolstered by fire and cheek. It’s a memorable performance, yes, but the film’s trailer is sufficient to convey what Oldman is doing as a performer. The best line of the movie — Churchill screaming his anti-appeasement credo, “You cannot reason with a tiger when your head is in its mouth!” — has unfortunately already been revealed.

It’s Wright’s filmmaking, dark, rich and full of immaculate framing, that folds the Churchill character into a time and place, and crucially shows the ways in which he often resisted such folding. We’re first introduced to Churchill by only the ember end of his cigar in a shadowy bedroom. Another masterful shot squares off the new Prime Minister, slouched in a lonely elevator, descending into the utter darkness of his Westminster bunker. He’s visually communicated to us as a rebel in the House of Commons and in the foyers of Buckingham Palace, while also being a product of such institutions, like a stately portrait that insists on hanging crookedly.

Oldman’s performance, while heavy and effortful, feels more like, say, Morgan Freeman in “Invictus” than Daniel Day-Lewis in “Lincoln.” It’s a subtle distinction, but the former is a topflight professional delivering a script pre-packaged to land as important. Such scripts, like this one by “Theory of Everything” screenwriter Anthony McCarten, know they must both evangelize for and humanize the subject. That means letting on during a family toast to his new national position that Churchill has neglected his wife Clementine (Kristin Scott Thomas) routinely through the years. It means showing that at times his whiskey pours stymied his ability to write and speak. It means showing through the eyes of Churchill’s personal typist (Lily James) that he could be cruel and curt. But the best biographical performances, like DDL in “Lincoln” or Natalie Portman in “Jackie,” are more inherently fascinating; the performances themselves thrive on both exceeding and defying the popular imagination. Humanizing isn’t something a script does; it’s something essential in acting, reintroducing unexpected, imperfect flavors to figures who’ve been diluted by history.

While the miracle of pulling off the real-life Dunkirk evacuation is made clear, “Darkest Hour” has a way of making Churchill appear too perfect for this midnight hour of the free world. His readiness to stir the masses over the radio and espouse the barbarism of Hitler don’t exactly suit the parliamentary intrigue that dominates the rest of the script. Large portions hang the tension on whether Neville Chamberlain (Ronald Pickup) and Viscount Halifax (Stephen Dillane) can catch Churchill on a political technicality and remove him from office. The plot’s nitty gritty is commendable, but it still has to work itself into a violin-fueled frenzy suitable for fighting on the beaches. This leaves the proceedings both boring down the stretch and maudlin in the end, a backward combination for a movie that I think fancies itself thriving on intrigue and sobriety.

Back to “Dunkirk.” Its best storytelling quality is a choice that was hiding in plain sight — demystify the war by showing it nakedly through the eyes of untrained teenagers and day sailors risking everything. Wright dresses the British resistance right back up in its top hat and coattails, and it could scarcely be a more traditional “good-bad” by our standards. In the jowliest movie in recent memory, I walked away feeling Gary Oldman is a shoe-in for Most Troubled Jowls this Oscar season.


SHARE fl

All The Movies We've Reviewed

101 Dalmatians
10 Cloverfield Lane
10 Things I Hate About You
127 Hours
22 Jump Street
A Dangerous Method
A Few Good Men
Air Force One
A League of Their Own
Alien
Alien 3
Alien: Covenant
Alien: Resurrection
Aliens
American Animals
American Hustle
American Made
American Psycho
Annihilation
Armageddon
Arrival
A Simple Plan
A Single Man
Atomic Blonde
Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me
AVP: Alien Vs. Predator
Baby Driver
Baby Mama
Bad Company
Bad Lieutenant
Bad Moms
Bad Santa
Basic Instinct
Batman Vs. Superman: Dawn of Justice
Beasts of No Nation
Beauty And The Beast
Beetlejuice
Before Sunrise
Behind Enemy Lines
Below
Birdman
Black Hawk Down
Black Mass
Black Panther
Blade Runner 2049
Bleed For This
Body Heat
Bongwater
Boogie Nights
Bowfinger
Bridge of Spies
Bright
Bull Durham
Call Me By Your Name
Capote
Captain Fantastic
Catch Me If You Can
Chariots Of Fire
Child's Play
Christmas Vacation
Chuck
Cinderella Man
Clue
Clueless
Cocktail
Con Air
Cool Runnings
Crimson Tide
Danny Collins
Dante's Peak
Dead Poets Society
Deep Blue Sea
Deep Impact
Deja Vu
Demolition Man
Dirty Dancing
Disclosure
Donnie Brasco
Drive
Dude, Where's My Car?
Dunkirk
Easy A
Eddie The Eagle
Ed Wood
Election
Employee of the Month
Erin Brockovich
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Event Horizon
Everybody Wants Some!!
Executive Decision
Ex Machina
Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them
Fargo
Fatal Attraction
Field Of Dreams
Finding Forrester
Flightplan
Flower
For Love Of The Game
Friday Night Lights
Game Night
Gangs of New York
Garden State
Gone Girl
Gone In Sixty Seconds
Grosse Pointe Blank
Hail, Caesar!
Half Baked
Harold And Kumar Go To White Castle
Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban
Head of State
Heavyweights
He Got Game
Hocus Pocus
Hollywood Ending
Hot Tub Time Machine
How High
Howl
Indiana Jones and The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
Infamous
Ingrid Goes West
Inherent Vice
Inside Man
Inside Out
In The Land Of Women
In The Line of Fire
Into The Wild
Invictus
It
I, Tonya
Jaws: The Revenge
John Wick
Joshy
Jurassic Park III
Jurassic World
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
Kill Bill, Vol. 1
King Cobra
Kingdom Of Heaven
Kiss Kiss Bang Bang
Lady Bird
La La Land
Leave No Trace
Less Than Zero
Lethal Weapon
Little Miss Sunshine
Looper
Love & Mercy
Mad Max: Fury Road
Matchstick Men
Matilda
Midnight Special
Million Dollar Arm
Miracle
Mississippi Grind
Mo' Better Blues
Mom and Dad
Money For Nothing
Monster
Moon
Moonlight
Moonrise Kingdom
Mr. Mom
Murder at 1600
My Cousin Vinny
National Lampoon's Vacation
Network
Never Say Never
Ocean's Twelve
Old School
One Hour Photo
Orange County
Out of Africa
Part of Me
Payback
Peter's Friends
Phantom Thread
Picture Perfect
Practical Magic
Prometheus
Public Enemies
Purple Rain
Raising Arizona
Red Dragon
Red Eye
Red Sparrow
Remember The Titans
Reversal Of Fortune
Room
Run All Night
Salt
Save The Last Dance
School Ties
Scream 2
Scrooged
Sharknado
Silence
Simply Complicated
Sleepaway Camp
Small Soldiers
Snakes On A Plane
Snowden
Solo: A Star Wars Story
Southside With You
Space Jam
Spectre
Speed
Sphere
Spy
Stargate
Star Wars: The Last Jedi
State and Main
Step Up
Steve Jobs
Sully
Sweet Home Alabama
Tag
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
The Addams Family
The Big Chill
The Big Sick
The Bling Ring
The Brady Bunch Movie
The Campaign
The Cell
The Cloverfield Paradox
The Color of Money
The Disaster Artist
The End of the Tour
The Family Man
The Fast and The Furious
The Fighter
The Flintstones
The Fly
The Fugitive
The Fundamentals of Caring
The Hateful Eight
The Holiday
The Hours
The Hunt For Red October
The Illusionist
The Indian In The Cupboard
The Insider
The Judge
The Jungle Book
The Last of the Mohicans
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
The Lost World: Jurassic Park
The Martian
The Matrix
The Matrix Reloaded
The Matrix Revolutions
The Mexican
The Mighty Ducks
The Mission
The Mosquito Coast
The Muppet Christmas Carol
The Natural
The Negotiator
The Nice Guys
The Night Before
The Pagemaster
The Perfect Storm
The Poseidon Adventure
The Prestige
The Queen
The Recruit
The Revenant
The Royal Tenenbaums
The Rules of Attraction
The Shallows
The Sixth Sense
The Social Network
The Taking Of Pelham One Two Three
The Truman Show
The Watch
The Witches of Eastwick
This Is Where I Leave You
Thoroughbreds
¬°Three Amigos!
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
Titanic
Tombstone
Traffic
Trainwreck
Tropic Thunder
Twister
Unfriended
Van Wilder
Varsity Blues
V For Vendetta
Volcano
Wall-E
Watchmen
Welcome To Me
While You Were Sleeping
White House Down
Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
Wild
Wild Things
Wild Wild West
Win It All
Wyatt Earp
Young Adult
Zack and Miri Make a Porno